See the results of the University Observer Irish unity poll
The question of Irish unification has not weighed so heavily on public discourse since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement. Since the start of this academic term, UCD has been abuzz with similar discussions on unification.
Catherine Connolly, throughout her election campaign had advocated for a united Ireland. This campaign was supported by the five major Irish left-leaning political parties (Sinn Féin, The Labour Party, The Social Democrats, People Before Profit, The Green Party). Connolly’s campaign was ultimately successful, with Connolly gaining 63% of first preference votes - much of this success has since been attributed to the support she garnered from young people in Ireland, particularly the movement ‘Youth for Connolly.’
Then in April in UCD, three SU sabbatical officers who were elected were all members of Sinn Féin.
At the start of college term, discussions surrounding Irish unification intensified. On September 14, the first ministers of Wales, Scotland, Northern Ireland met and discussed respective independence referendums. Plaid Cymru leader, Rhun ap Iorwerth; Scottish National party leader, John Swinney; Sinn Féin’s vice-president, Michelle O’Neill, and the president and leader of the opposition in Ireland, Mary Lou McDonald, met in Cardiff and signed a memorandum of understanding recognising that “the political landscape across these islands is changing”. This memorandum called for the British government to “prepare for, plan and facilitate constitutional changes” in Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.
Also On the global stage, world leaders US President Donald Trump and British Prime Minister Andy Burnham expressed opposing views on the issue. While Trump stated that he would “love to see” Ireland unified, and that “it’s going to happen eventually. It may as well happen now”, Burnham ruled out a referendum on Irish unification, calling a border poll “off the table.”
That same month, UCD’s Law Society hosted a debate “This House Would Fight for a United Ireland.” Speakers for the proposition included former SDLP leader and MP Alastair McDonnell, human rights campaigner Emma de Souza, and former TD and Minister Conor Lenihan. Speakers for the opposition included economist John Fitzgerald, chair of the Ulster Young Unionists Jay Basra, political journalist Pat Leahy. The various speeches included callbacks to the signing of the Anglo-Irish Treaty, personal testimonies of life in Northern Ireland, the question of the cost of unification, and the risk of returning to the everyday sectarian violence which claimed the lives of so many for decades.
While O’Donnell called a United Ireland “a fight worth having,” and de Souza stated “it is very easy to talk about how much a united Ireland will cost, when you are not the one being costed”, Leahy brought up the issue of the concessions. He said that when asking questions about a United Ireland, you must also ask “how British are you prepared to be,” referencing the British identity of many unionists in Northern Ireland. The house eventually voted in favour of a united Ireland.
Amidst the commentary from world leaders, local tensions were sparked on the Garvaghy Road. protests have taken place to cease an Orange Order parade from completing its traditional route from Drumcree Church through the nationalist area of Garvaghy Road for the first time in almost 30 years. The stand-off has continued since September 27, attracting high levels of media attention, including a ‘Gig for Garvaghy’, open letters signed by various celebrities, police letters to politicians and legal disputes.
In view of these discussions, a highly publicized summit, and protests, The University Observer conducted a poll with hundreds of UCD students on the subject of Irish unity. The poll showed that 91.1% of respondents voted ‘yes’ in favour of a united Ireland.
The poll further revealed that despite a large number of respondents expressing support for a united Ireland, only 71.4% said they would vote “yes” for Northern Ireland to unite with the Republic of Ireland if a referendum were held “tomorrow”. Meanwhile, just over half of students, with a 66.7% “yes” vote, believe they will see a united Ireland in their lifetime.
Political and cultural compromises may accompany a united Ireland, the poll explored these concessions and if students would be willing to make them as part of a potential reunification process.
In the poll, only 42.4% of respondents said they would be able to “confidently explain what the Good Friday Agreement is,” with 50.8% saying they “know what it is, but would not be able to explain it well”. Despite this, strong responses were still provided to the following questions.
Of those surveyed, 40% said they would be willing to pay higher taxes to fund health and education, making it the most commonly supported concession in the poll. 31% said they would consider changing the Irish flag or national anthem, while 15% expressed support for allowing Orange Order parades to take place. A further 10% said they would be willing to change the status of the Irish language, and 7% said they would support joining the Commonwealth. However, 34% of respondents said they would not be willing to make any concessions.
The poll also explored whether students believed a united Ireland would be worth the potential costs associated with reunification. When asked whether a united Ireland would be worth the risk of potential violence, 47.7% of respondents voted “no”, compared to 25.1% who voted “yes”. Responses were more favourable when students were asked about the economic cost of reunification. A majority of 58.1% of the poll believed a united Ireland would be worth the economic cost. There was greater willingness to accept the potential economic costs of reunification than the risk of potential violence.
In one response to the poll, a student expanded on their answer regarding potential violence, stating, “You could expect small riots of course, but nobody wants to go back to the Troubles.”
The question of whether a united Ireland would be worth the economic cost prompted varying responses, with students considering both the potential financial benefits and the risks associated with reunification. One respondent argued that the economic burden may be less significant than some anticipate, stating:
“We have a budget surplus of millions of euros each year, and considering the add on of a couple hundred thousand more taxpayers from uniting the country, I feel that the economic cost would not burden the potential new state. The problem, as with most new initiatives or political decisions in Ireland that bear a heavy cost, is the problem of how public money is spent/where public money is allocated.”
Others expressed concern that the financial implications could place further pressure on struggling public services and vulnerable groups. One respondent explained:
“No, purely because the areas that would take a hit would be things in danger already, like education, students, housing. And the stress of the cost would also be taken out on immigrants.”
Another student stated that economic costs are not irrelevant, but did not think they are a “permanent argument against unity. The economic impact would only be worth it if Ireland were fundamentally restructured and if the new federal provinces had the freedom to pursue serious pro-growth reform.”
When asked in the poll if students believed that there are fewer sectarian tensions in Northern Ireland today, 53% voted “yes”, with 30.3% voting “no”. One student claimed that they would have believed there were fewer tensions “up until talks of a united Ireland began,” while another student said “it is less violent, but it is questionable whether true reconciliation had occurred.”
One respondent commented on how sectarianism still exists, but “in a different form nowadays compared to the Troubles. Paramilitaries still exist in the north and have social influence in their communities, continuing the ideas of sectarianism. Sectarianism and paramilitaries seem more covert today and with the rise of the far-right globally, these tensions seem to be heightened and/or show up in new ways.”
A number of respondents believed that peace in Northern Ireland is “too fragile at this stage to reunite Ireland in the next 10 years”, expanding that “the official status of a land area is less urgent and of lower priority than the survival and safety of the people that live there. But I believe at this stage even proposing that as a vote would cause escalation and possible violence and deaths which so many people worked so hard to end.”
The University Observer spoke to three students: one whose family is from Northern Ireland and now lives in Dublin, one from a border county who has attended both Queen's University Belfast and UCD, and a student from Northern Ireland who now studies in UCD.
The first student, whose family are originally from Northern Ireland, said:
“Sectarianism and violence due to sectarianism, or even the potential of violence, is what should come at the forefront of thought when thinking about a united Ireland,” the student said. “Enforcing a significant part of the population of Northern Ireland to do something they don’t want to do seems very wrong and slightly hypocritical. The only people that should ever be able to vote on the commencement of a unity process are the people of Northern Ireland. The people of Northern Ireland are not “part” of the process, they are the core of the process.”
“When you ask someone who wants united Ireland, and why they want it; they can’t give you a proper answer. "We are on an island, why wouldn’t it all be one?’ is not good enough,” the student continued. “If we just look at the past 14 days on Garvaghy Road, it is clear that sectarianism is still on a tipping point. I’d invite anyone who wants a united Ireland tomorrow to take a trip up North, and experience the demarcation of territory, be it Republican or Unionist; you might be quite surprised.”
The student who studied at UCD and Queens University Belfast told The University Observer of his experience in studying in both the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland and living on the border, “caught between two communities, two states, two ideologies”. They stated that they think there is a tendency to “overlook the changes that need to happen”, in favour of a more “romantic view of Ireland united once more”.
A UCD student from Northern Ireland also spoke to The University Observer about their view on a united Ireland, and how it is shaped by their experience of the two states. “Discussions around the possibility of a united Ireland have always felt slightly different to me.” In Northern Ireland, expressions of identity, be it ‘Northern Irish, Irish or British’ become conflated with “political statements.” This included “what you wore, the language you spoke, where you lived and the sports you played.”
The student described how “moving to the Republic for university was incredibly refreshing.” They could wear GAA jumpers, learn Irish, “without anyone making a comment or questioning my motivation behind doing it.”
The student also faced “passing commentary” and “harmless jokes” in relation to the topic of Northern Ireland. The student described how they could be talked down to by those who knew “dates and names of events from the Troubles.” The student affirmed that “knowing the history of a place is not the same as living with its consequences.”
The student continued: “This is what makes conversations about a united Ireland complicated for me. In the Republic, there is a freedom to express Irish identity that I did not always experience growing up. You can wear a jersey, sing a rebel song, and discuss politics over a pint without necessarily thinking about who might be sitting beside you and what their family has experienced. For some people, the Troubles are merely a historical event, whereas for others it’s all that they understand of society.”
Because of this, the student told the University Observer, they believe that the “people of Northern Ireland must ultimately have the voice in deciding it. They are the ones who would have to live with the consequences, including any potential instability or sectarian violence. That also means respecting unionists that grew up in society alongside us. They were born into their identity just as I was born into mine.”
They continued, “someone from the Republic can have very strong opinions about a united Ireland, despite having maybe only visited Belfast once on a childhood day trip. They can cross the border as a curious visitor and return home. For people living in Northern Ireland, it is not simply somewhere you visit to get a history lesson...it is home.”
The student concluded, “I can understand why a united Ireland is an appealing idea to many people. But it cannot simply be about erasing a supposed line on a map. It has to recognise the people who live there; the Irish people, British people, and others somewhere between those identities, that make up that society; that history and legacy. The future of Ireland should not be decided by who has the strongest historical argument, but rather with an understanding of the people who will actually have to live with it.”