Apple’s $299 HomeView has earned a warm review from The Verge, alongside an uncomfortable finding about family privacy: reviewer Jennifer Pattison Tuohy says she could sometimes remain on her teenage daughter’s profile and read her text messages after taking over the display. Her November 12 review arrives ahead of HomeView’s scheduled November 13 launch. Source Source
Tuohy gave Apple’s first smart display a 7/10, praising its fast home controls, guided cooking and compact hardware. But its attempt to put personal information on a communal screen proved less convincing. Source
The awkward part is handing it over
HomeView has a seven-inch square touchscreen and is designed to recognize up to six household members through their faces and voices, giving each access to personal information including messages and calendars. The intended arrangement is a shared device, not shared access to everyone’s conversations. Source
Tuohy reports that the separation sometimes broke down immediately after her daughter used it. If she approached within roughly five seconds of her daughter leaving, she could sometimes scroll through the messages for up to 10 seconds before another check locked her out. The device could recognize Tuohy and offer to switch profiles while still allowing access to her daughter’s texts, she writes. She conducted the tests with her daughter’s consent. Source
She also describes being able to read her daughter’s messages while both were near the screen, and continuing after her daughter moved to a couch in the same room. Tuohy attributed that continued access to the camera still seeing her daughter rather than switching to Tuohy, who was closer to the display. Source
Tuohy says swiping out of Messages to a home face and leaving the room was the most reliable protection she found, but it wasn’t foolproof. Source
Other households got different results
At 9to5Mac, Chance Miller reports that trying to open Messages while HomeView was on his wife’s profile produced an identity-verification error. Repeated attempts eventually required her to authenticate with her iPhone. Daily Mail reviewer Shivali Best likewise says her messages disappeared when her husband looked at the screen, replaced by a recognition requirement. Source Source
Joanna Stern’s New Things review also describes successful checks: HomeView switched to her children’s accounts when they tried to access her messages, and refused access when Stern disguised her face. Those tests took place in different households, with different procedures. Why Tuohy could read another profile’s messages while others were blocked remains unclear. Source Source Source Source
WIRED reports that HomeView uses a new person-recognition system rather than Face ID, alongside checks for a recently unlocked iPhone or iPad on the same Wi-Fi network. Source
Better at dinner than at being another iPhone
Tuohy says HomeView switched on her entryway lights as quickly as a conventional light switch. Its guided cooking interface turns supported Safari recipes into steps with tappable timers, although other reviewers found website compatibility limits. Source Source Source
Siri AI, still in beta according to Tuohy, was less consistently helpful. She reports slow personal-context answers and errors; Miller found those requests useful overall but also encountered hangs. Stern describes Siri getting stuck for three minutes after her son asked what 10 times 40 was. That’s a long wait for 400. Source Source Source
There’s also no App Store. HomeView combines built-in apps with selected audio and video apps through a CarPlay-based system, rather than offering the full flexibility of an iPhone. Tuohy found missing apps and unfinished tasks repeatedly sending her back to her phone. So much for giving that phone the evening off. Source Source
Tuohy still calls HomeView a good choice for iPhone or iPad owners interested in its core features, particularly smart-home control. “But potentially seeing each other’s texts will be a deal-breaker for some,” she writes. Source
Comments