Soundtrack Review: Man Of Steel (2013)

Soundtrack Review: Man Of Steel (2013)

Man Of Steel Soundtrack Review: This is a review of the film score Man Of Steel by Hans Zimmer.

Hans Zimmer is a superhero. The question is: Is he a villain or a hero? Is he General Zod or Superman? Is he forcing his evil ways upon us or showing us a more ideal way of living? Whatever you might think of the man, there is no question about his force in film scoring. From his action scores in the 90s to the modern two note or even one note themes from The Dark Knight trilogy. He infuriates and pleases the soundtrack listener and is even a more controversial figure than James Horner these days. The purists, the soundtrack geeks of old will no doubt hate this score and will use every ounce of their energy to bash it as nothing more than generic droning music. For the rest of us, I believe the new bold direction the Superman franchise is taking is both brilliant and brave. Superman deserves this score and so do you.

Let’s be honest though, Hans Zimmer has created some awful scores and if we’re to believe my Soundtrack Index, then Hans Zimmer is not even in the top 30’s of my top composer list. When Zimmer is good though, he is very good and the recent sound he has created for The Dark Knight trilogy and Inception has been wonderful to my old ears. He is currently on a winning streak and can’t seem to do much wrong. He had me worried though because the 30 second samples I heard of the score was worrying. Where was the fun? Not even when longer samples arrived and even a few tracks I was suitably impressed. I almost lost hope, but if there’s one thing Superman, the man of steel stands for, it’s hope and I’m glad I didn’t give it up.

Let’s talk a little about the elephant in the room first. Everyone, including me was worried sick of what Zimmer might do with the franchise. We knew it was going to be a reboot and that Snyder was going to direct it. It was then confirmed that the main theme from Superman composed by John Williams would not be in it. Sacrilege! screamed a thousand soundtrack and Superman nerds to no avail. A superman score without John Williams immaculate theme is like toast without butter, it cannot possibly work! But wait, it worked for Batman and who was responsible? Zimmer of course, and we all knew what was coming. But then there’s the legacy of Superman and I don’t know how you can take away John Williams theme from Superman, not the Superman I knew anyway. This however, will be a new Superman without Christopher Reeve, without Richard Donner, without John Williams and it’s all a good thing. This is how a proper reboot should be done. A John Williams-esque score would simply not work in Snyder & Nolan’s vision of the Man Of Steel, and that’s why they turned to Hans Zimmer who managed to re-invigorate the sound for another iconic character, Batman. How great was the John Williams Superman score? Does it matter? Is it of any consequence to this score that the main theme for Superman is the best theme ever written? It shouldn’t, but for some it always will. Whenever people say that Superman by John Williams is a great score, I’m pretty sure that 80% of them means the main theme (and possibly the love theme). The rest of that score is really not that great, but the main theme is the best theme I have ever heard, bar none. Zimmer’s Man Of Steel score is overall of a much higher quality than John Williams Superman score, but doesn’t have a theme that will last forever. That’s my opinion anyway.

We’ve all heard the brilliant trailer music and was told it was an edited version of themes heard in Man Of Steel. Luckily they didn’t edit much except added some guitars and extended it a little, and it can be heard in all it’s glory in ‘What Are You Going To Do When You Are Not Saving The World’. There are many themes sprinkled in here, a lot of them in-your-face, but also many themes that are not so apparent. If you are looking for a John Williams-esque march, you won’t find it and it’s definitely not needed. Personally I have been humming a couple of themes from the Man Of Steel score non-stop after I listened to it and that’s not something you can say about every score out there.

Hans Zimmer has had some amazing scores created over the years, but this stands as his crown achievement, the score of a lifetime. It’s damn near perfect. You don’t have to wait for the trailer theme to enjoy this. In almost every cue, there’s a beautiful theme and there’s so many of them and what’s even better is that they really sound heroic for Superman and pure evil for Zod. Speaking of Zod, how great it is to hear a proper bad guy theme for a baddie in the Superman universe. ‘Arcade’ is only on the Deluxe edition and that one track alone is worth the purchase of that edition. Check out the magnificent and evil tones of Zod and his followers starting at 4:22 and the fantastic drums coming right after with the brutal sound of Zod.

My biggest enjoyment on this score has to be the 28 minute+ monster cue ‘Man Of Steel (Hans’ Original Sketchbook)’ which really is 28 minutes of pure bliss. You get all the themes and more of Hans’ amazing music. This piece is a true showstopper and possibly the best cue Hans has ever written. There are really only two composers who can succeed in making epic long tracks and that’s James Horner and Hans Zimmer. They nail it almost every time where others have failed.

The percussion on this score is stellar. The sound of it and how it’s used is simply brilliant, but on it’s own like ‘This Is Madness!’ is simply madness and the one cue I couldn’t give 5 stars to. I bet it sounds fantastic in surround though. Man, when Zimmer hit those drums in ‘You Die Or I Do’ it’s crazy, specially when the Zod sound comes in I swear I am having the time of my life. I do love percussion, and specially of the heavy kind. The percussion that John Powell used for “Green Zone” was awesome and even James Newton Howard has learned how to use them properly in Snow White. The enthusiasm of the people creating this score is awesome and it’s audible on ‘Oil Rig’. Right before the massive drum section near the beginning you can hear a muffled ‘Let’s go!’ which is a brilliant touch by Zimmer to leave it there.

Is there anyone mastering ostinatos as Hans Zimmer does? The thing is that he experiments and find those perfect harmonious tones that is just ripe for repetition. It was very present in my previous favorite Hans Zimmer cue ‘A Dark Knight’, but he always changes the pitch or make it more powerful, just like he does with the fantastic two note dark guitar theme heard first in ‘Look To The Stars’. It has to be the best two notes since John Williams famous Jaws theme. The way it grow from a simplistic, but awe-inspiring guitar rolls until absolute epic-ness with horns in ‘What Are You Going To Do When You Are Not Saving The World?’ is sheer perfection. There is a chain of restaurants in Indonesia called “Gelatto Bar” which has the most delicious glazed & grilled salmon ever, and whenever I go there I want to eat that and it’s exactly like that with Hans Zimmer’s ostinatos. I don’t need to hear other stuff when I have the absolute best in Zimmer’s scores.

How was the score inside the movie? It was perfect and easily identifiable. I love how Zimmer has used dialogue from the movie for his titles, and it all makes sense when you see the movie, like why does ‘Goodbye My Son’ end so abruptly? When you see the movie, you’ll know why. Also, I listened to the score again today after seeing the movie and I didn’t think watching the movie would change anything, but it did. I can’t hold back my tears now when I listen to ‘Goodbye My Son’, ‘Krypton’s Last’ and specially ‘Tornado’. Zod did his part for the music as well. The awesome ‘You Die or I Do’ felt even better in the movie and listening to ‘Terraforming’ I was just scared out of my mind because the terrible scenes, man those were brutal. I don’t want to spoil it for anyone who hasn’t seen the movie yet, but I have to mention the awesome lullaby for Superman featuring the voice of Hilda Orvarsdottir. It’s beautiful both inside and outside of the film. The DNA theme heard in ‘DNA’ is a great cue by itself, but watching the movie, it all comes together. Love the way Hans adds that theme to other pivotal points in the movie such as ‘I Have So Many Questions’. The violin theme in ‘Krypton’s Last’ is touching and sad and going back to it after watching the movie brings me to tears.

In the end it doesn’t matter what I say to you. You have to make up your own mind about this, so ignore it at your peril! There will be haters and there will those who love this. I can’t think of a single reason to hate this glorious masterpiece of modern film music. It is, for me, Hans Zimmer’s most wonderful film score and one that I can’t stop listening to it. Even when I am not listening to it, I am humming the various themes. I still love the Williams Superman theme and I always will. Even now when I think of Superman, I am thinking of that theme first, but then I quickly realise there’s a new fantastic score and the new themes take over. Finally I have to add that I think it’s awesome that we get to hear some retro Hans in cues like ‘Man Of Steel (Hans’ Original Sketchbook) and ‘Earth’. Kudos! I feel like I am forgetting so much, and I really have a hard time stopping to write about this. I don’t think I have been this excited about a score since Blade Runner by Vangelis. I probably should write more about the lovely Clark Kent theme in ‘This Is Clark Kent’ and the superb flying theme in ‘Flight’ and I could go on and on. I just have to let this review go at some point and if you read this whole thing, I applaud you!

HIGHLIGHTS:
DISC 1:
1. Look At The Stars
2. Oil Rig
3. Sent Here For A Reason
4. DNA
5. Goodbye My Son
6. If You Love These People
7. Krypton’s Last
8. Terraforming
9. Tornado
10. You Die Or I Do
11. Launch
12. Ignition
13. I Will Find Him
14. This is Clark Kent
15. I Have So Many Questions
16. Flight

DISC 2:
1. What Are You Going When You Are Not Saving The World?
2. Man Of Steel (Hans’ Original Sketchbook)
3. Are You Listening Clark?
4. General Zod (Junkie XL)
5. You Led Us Here
7. Earth
8. Arcade (Junkie XL)

GEEK SCORE (Standard Edition): 100
GEEK SCORE (Deluxe Edition): 99.1

GD Star Rating
loading...
Soundtrack Review: Man Of Steel (2013), 8.2 out of 10 based on 162 ratings

Author

Creator of Soundtrackgeek.com and Soundtracks community on Google Plus.
  • Gary Muldoon

    Wow.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Too many… words?

  • Ben’jamin’ Ross

    Don’t get me wrong; I do enjoy Hans Zimmer a good deal – I love all of his work for the Dark Knight Trilogy, Pirates of the Caribbean, Sherlock Holmes, Inception, etc. Nevertheless, this entire score was a complete disappointment. I can understand the new, “dark” direction of Superman, but Zimmer just gave us The Dark Knight Rises retooled with more percussion. Except for the few standout tracks like “Flight” or “DNA,” the score is very mediocre and generic.

    • Jørn Tillnes

      I think this is very different from TDKR. That one was very dark while Man Of Steel is uplifting and hopeful for the most part. Even in the sad cues there are glimmer’s of hope. If anything this would be more of a Batman Begins except with a lot more themes.

      • http://www.jmsartworks.com Javier Martinez

        Hello,
        Wow! I can notice a kind of CRUSADE in order to protect the integrity of this “new” work of Zimmer…isn´t that true?
        I´ve read several reviews of soundtracks here and I´ve been pretty much in the same direction with my feelings and thoughts…
        But let me express that I can´t understand how can a truly bad, uninspired, boring, monotone, noisy, without fun or excitement, no epic moments, no hero, no interesting thematic material nor ideas….and a lot of details that give a film score the quality of enjoyable or memorable stuff!
        Is not too much even mention that this exercise of minimalistic and disappointing hollow music can be better in quality than John Williams´Superman? I´ve heard things really odd and distempered but this can be considered for a kind of Guinness records!
        Look, I really love film music and I´ve embraced it since I was a kid…They´ve opened my mind, I´ve felt the emotion, the influence of them into my life and I´ve learned so much of a lot of composers and their legacy, from Max Steiner until today. And what a great amount of music are there!
        Is for that reason I really can´t really understand this amazing and intemperate attempt to put this mediocre and forgetable Man of Steel soundtrack as a milestone in the film music history!
        Give me a break!

        • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

          I am just being honest and to be fair, there’s more of a Zimmer hate crusade online if you check other review sites. It’s just one of those scores that brings out emotions in people, good or bad. Deal with it or skip the reviews and make your own opinion :)

  • Bo Digidy

    Man of Steel is easily the most fun I have had with a Zimmer score in some time. Shame the Lois theme couldn’t make it to the album. Also of note is that Z+ app. 11.1 trough the headphones. What a difference.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Yes, fun! I’m having so much fun with this score at the moment. Even in the short time I have listened to it it has become my most listened score of all time. Love the Z+ app as well. Superb for the percussion bits.

  • http://www.twitter.com/rogerahlin Roger

    Wow, you didn’t hold back writing this one :-). This must be one of your favorite scores of all time then, considering the score?

    Let’s face it, a lot of critics downright hates it so I’m happy to read a review that showed the opposite. Personally I don’t love it, I don’t hate it either. I think it’s pretty enjoyable and for sure has it’s moments where it’s really really good. It’s just as I expected it to be like. I don’t really understand those who claims that the lacking of the Williams main theme or a strong new one, killed the score. I would be bored if they used it again and regarding a new one, I think he does a really good job.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Yeah it was hard letting this one go. I could probably write a book about this score and my love for it. It’s definitely in my top 10 scores of all time.

  • Ryan Mott

    I felt like Zimmer pulled more from Gladiator and Inception for this one. It’s hard to ignore the gladiator-esque choir voices and there’s lots of tracks that meander (in a good way) in order to give the listener that mysterious/ominous feel from Inception (and maybe Batman Begins). The main difference between the Batman and Superman score is that Zimmer trades in the industrial/foley sounds for soft piano keys and blaring horns/synths. I think most listeners are glad to hear a completely different take on the Superman score (even if it’s awfully reminiscent of the Batman score).

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      I felt it was very different than TDK and specially TDKR, but it does borrow from Inception and also his 90s scores which was incredibly fun for me.

      • Ryan Mott

        I was THIS close to mentioning some of his earlier stuff like Days of Thunder – so glad you picked up on the 90s stuff! It’s like he took some of that youthful cheese-guitar and somehow matured into an epic score.

        • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

          I loooove that guitar! I was surprised he brought that back and there’s also references to Gladiator and POTC. He said he was finished doing scores like that, but I guess he was referring to the score as a whole. I was pleasantly surprised anyway.

  • Linwood Riley

    the score was the perfect engine for this film…. I’m not the biggest fan of the Man of Steel; that goes to my wife…. but this Bat-Fan was delighted to hear the man responsible for bringing Batman back to life in music breathed life back into Superman… excuse me for being a Han Loyalist….. but he and his “Barbarian Horde” have been kicking tail in the business lately….

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      “Barbarian Horde” I like the reference. Well played!

      Yep, leave it to Hans. Just debuted at nr. 9 on the Billboard Top 200 Albums chart. Not bad!

  • Chiaraaa

    I did enjoy it a lot, some really cool themes and amazing sounds. I LOVED the trailer music and really searched for it in the score, though not played a whole lot, it worked well (Its lengthening did throw me off a little since I’m so used to listening to the trailer version) A good Z-score but Zimmer’s best score for me has to go to The Last Samurai.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      The Last Samurai is indeed a fantastic score. Up there with Zimmer’s best.

  • omak

    you always overrate scores

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Well I guess I just love scores more than those who rate them lower than me :)

      • http://www.twitter.com/rogerahlin Roger

        True that! You nailed it Jorn :-D.

        • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

          Thanks!

  • doanyouknowit

    well said! in fact, come to think of it – john williams does typically super succeed in composing amazing themes (a lot of his scores are amazing) BUT imo, hans just creates these incredible scores, that wrap around the storyline of a film and pull you in. his scores are more than just great, they make the movie that much better. this one is not my most favorite, but high up there. i agree with another comment below, the trailer music is just awesome. overall a very solid score, not to be doubted by one of the best! ps. its refreshing to see a high score, why is everyone afraid to give someone max credit??

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      My thoughts exactly.

      I don’t know why it’s “popular” to give low ratings to scores. It’s great to just let yourself go and just enjoy a score. It’s in those moments that I think I’m the luckiest guy alive that gets to listen to these fantastic score. We are priveleged and these are great times to be a soundtrack geek.

  • Marc Joseph Sison

    I agree with you for the most part of the review except for this: “Zimmer’s Man Of Steel score is overall of a much higher quality than John Williams Superman score, but doesn’t have a theme that will last forever.” I really love Zimmer’s music for Man of Steel (4/5). He did a score that will please modern audiences plus Williams’ music will be out of context in the film. But in my opinion, the themes that John Williams created is superior compared to Zimmer. The Krypton theme, Love theme,of course the Main theme, and the rest of the score is saturated by Williams’ mannerisms and conveys optimism, heroism and patriotism in a grander scale compared to what Zimmer did.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Which is why I wrote just before: “Whenever people say that Superman by John Williams is a great score, I’m pretty sure that 80% of them means the main theme (and possibly the love theme). The rest of that score is really not that great, but the main theme is the best theme I have ever heard, bar none.” Emphasis on the last bit. Apart from the main theme in the original Superman, Zimmer’s themes are superior and are the ones I hum, whistle and sing to on a daily basis now :)

  • https://twitter.com/dnwilliams dnwilliams

    I was upset and a little angered by the actual film, but the score remains impressive. Very atmospheric, and the main theme is wonderful. It’s funny, I do love the Williams theme, and I’ll always be biased towards it, but there’s something about themes for the Superman character IN GENERAL I just love. Even the melodies for the old Fleischer cartoons, the Timm one and Lois and Clark…people really live up to the character when they write a theme for him!

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      I was one of the lucky few who loved the film, but yes, every Superman theme or score is something special. I was disappointed with the score to Smallville, at least the album they released. I swear there’s more impressive stuff they didn’t release.

      • TCK1995

        I loved Man of Steel too.

        Oh, and there was so much more impressive music that didn’t get a soundtrack release on Smallville, like the recap music / rise of the Fortress of Solitude in ‘Arrival’ (which actually samples John Williams’ ‘Fortress of Solitude’), Clark’s proposal to Lana in ‘Reckoning’, the recap music in ‘Bizarro’, the death of Lionel Luthor music from ‘Descent’, ‘Eternal’, and ‘Upgrade’ (how did this not make it?!), the train wreck and introduction of the Blur in ‘Savior’, that nice bad guy steampunk music from when John’s shooting up in ‘Upgrade’, Clark and Zod’s showdown in ‘Salvation’, or Clark’s resurrection in ‘Lazarus’. The soundtrack for Smallville focused too much on it’s final season when there were so many other great pieces from the second half of the show.

  • Brian

    I’m so glad to read a review in which someone finally understood how beautiful Zimmer’s work was in this. This may be the best score I’ve heard in a very long time. I’m surprised you mad no mention of the track “General Zod.” The last two minutes or so are simply incredible. It’s cool how he took that the same theme featured in “Arcade” and slowed it down into something amazingly emotional and impacting.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      Yeah there’s just too much to like on this score. I could probably have doubles the amount of words writing about every cue, but I managed to stop in time :). General Zod is a wonderful cue.

  • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

    Thanks!

  • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

    Nah, we’re just being honest :)

  • Stephen Noell

    Finally got around to seeing the movie and listening to the soundtrack. I can see why this score is so polarizing now…either you enjoy Zimmer and his style of modern film score writing, or you don’t. This is Zimmer at his absolute finest, perhaps the most Zimmer-esque soundtrack out there, and I love it. Sure, his themes aren’t amazingly long and intricate like Williams, but his themes are short and sweet and memorable (can’t stop humming them…), and his action music is sweet (love the percussion for the most part), the intimate/quiet music is beautiful, all around an amazing soundtrack. Movie was great too :)

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      True, it’s a very Zimmer-esque score and if you hate that, then I have no problem understanding people’s hate for this score.

      What I can’t understand is the superiority complex some have just because I enjoy different music than them. You have no idea how many comments I had to put in the spam box because of name calling just because I dared to criticise the old Superman score by Williams. Sheesh, it’s just music people…

      Btw, glad you loved the movie. I did too. It was just what I wanted and more :)

  • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

    Ow, I can’t even remember that one I’m afraid. Will have to go back to listen to it at some point :)

  • Gergely Bakay

    Before anything I must underline: I love Zimmer and his music, and his music was that made me love film music. I followed his career since King Arthur and discovered many many great soundtracks, scores, melodies, tunes. But recently I feel like Zimmer has lost his ‘edge’.

    He is minimalistic melodically, using many many ostinatos, electronic effects, or over-grandious instrumentation (like 10 drummers in Man of Steel soundtrack, or extended brass section in Inception) just to hide the fact that his melodic sound-scape lacks of creativity.

    Just compare this score melodically with Lion King, Peacemaker, Gladiator, Beyond Rangoon, Regarding Henry, The Thin Red Line, and other 90’s scores! The ‘fire’, the passion, the soul seems to be missing for me! Maybe it’s just me, or I have changed, but I think Zimmer went a wrong direction with this Remote Control and team work approach. Not to mention that it seems lot of trailer music ideas seems to be brought here too plus he is overly repeating his previous ideas, motifs and melodies.

    With it we will get well crafted, but medicore scores without any individual characteristics, generating ‘I’ve heard this somewhere else’ moments, because so many people works on it that it got simply lost.

    So to sum up: the Man of Steel score does not deliver for me what I love(d) in Zimmer and made me love the film scores! It is good, no question but not that brilliant, inspiring that Zimmer would be able to compose!

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      You make good points, but I think every composer needs change and unfortunately for some it’s been for the worse and for some it’s been for the better. That’s life :). Personally I enjoy these “experiments” that Zimmer seems to be enjoying as well. In his next score “The Lone Ranger” he is apparently experimenting with train sounds so I’m very curious about that. To me, Zimmer is more of a sound designer now, but that excites me. I miss his “true” composing days and visit his excellent scores to Gladiator, The Last Samurai and others quite frequently, but I wouldn’t replace this Zimmer with the old one.

      He hasn’t lost it though as there was plenty of retro Zimmer in Man Of Steel, so I think we will hear bits and pieces of it in future scores. I have high hopes for “Rush” which should be more of a 80s/90s score. We’ll see :)

  • Thaissa Resek

    Wow, you wrote almost everything I think about this score. I could’t agree more with you. This score is absolutely amazing.
    I have to say that when I first listened the score, I hadn’t seen the movie yet, and it got my expectations higher for the movie, because the score was absolutely marvelous.
    I won’t spoil it, but I confess that only after I’ve seen the movie I got all the power and tension from “If You Love These People”, it turned out to be one of my favourite tracks.

    • http://soundtrackgeek.com/ Jørn Tillnes

      True, only after I saw the movie I “understood” some cues on the score and it all fits so well. Marvelous score.

  • http://www.tecnogaming.com/ Alex Vojacek

    I read it completely. I agree with you 100%, in fact if you take a close look at the movie. This is the kind of movie that has “magic” happening all over the place. CGI, actors, music, everything fits, everything works, this can be best describe as the “they got it right, magic was present”. And Hans Zimmer was in huge part, responsable for this.

  • Sreekiran

    Zimmer comes back in the Man of Steel. The beats in this film are hell as you can get. The beats get all the weight needed. Oil rig has the sensational start to Zimmer, it continues with three elevating tracks like flight, ignition and good bye my son, The original power of Zimmer is shown in the theme song. Arguably I am not in a position to compare the original theme with this. But this is modern score and theme for superman. Nothing can get better than this. ZImmer once again rocks the park. Tune up the speakers and enjoy the beats at murderous way.

  • Arkadiusz Malcahn

    My favourite soundtrack of all time.

⌂