Keeping an eye on the debt-to-income ratio, which set off all alarm bells before the Housing Bust; but so far, so good.
By Wolf Richter for WOLF STREET.
Mortgage balances rose by $257 billion in Q3, to $13.37 trillion, after having declined in Q2, according to the Household Debt and Credit Report from the New York Fed, which gets the data from Equifax.
The decline in Q2 had been “due to a temporary gap in the reporting of mortgages on credit reports due to a transfer of servicing,” the New York Fed had explained at the time. And now the missed mortgage data from Q2 was included in Q3, which caused part of the jump, after the decline.
Year-over-year, mortgage balances rose by $302 billion, or by 2.3%.
Here come the HELOCs: +52% since Q1 2021.
Balances of Home Equity Lines of Credit spiked by 4.9% in Q3, and by 14.0% year-over-year, to $481 billion in actual balances drawn on HELOCs (not including the unused portion of the credit lines).
Since the low point in 2021, HELOC balances have surged by 52%.
HELOCs are second-lien loans on the home. They increase leverage and, if defaulted on, can lead to foreclosure and loss of the home, even if the first-lien mortgage is current. HELOCs add an additional layer of risk for homeowners, lenders, and the mortgage market, and they did some additional damage during the Housing Bust and Mortgage Crisis.
HELOC versus cash-out refinancing. If homeowners want to pull cash out of their home equity, they can choose between refinancing the entire existing mortgage with a larger new mortgage; or keeping the existing mortgage and adding a much smaller second-lien mortgage, such as a HELOC. The math depends on the interest rate of the original mortgage. If that’s a 3% mortgage with a big balance, homeowners wanting to extract cash would be tilting to a HELOC, and so HELOC balances have been surging.
The burden of housing debt and defaults.
A debt-to-income ratio is a standard metric to evaluate the burden of a debt for the purpose of gauging credit risk (risk of default) – and in this case, the economy-wide credit risk. To get total “housing debt,” I combine all mortgages and HELOCs. And for income, I use disposable income (by the Bureau of Economic Analysis).
Disposable income consists of after-tax wages, plus income from interest, dividends, rentals, farm income, small business income, transfer payments from the government, etc.
But it excludes capital gains, which is where the wealthy make most of their money. Excluded are thereby all incomes from stock-based compensation plans and capital appreciation where billionaires make their billions.
Disposable income has grown over the years because the number of households has grown over the years, and income per household has grown, and it has grown faster than housing debt, so the debt-to-income ratio has declined over the years.
In Q3, the debt-to-income ratio rose to 57.2%, after declining in Q2. The ratios in Q2 and Q3 were the third and fourth lowest in the data, behind only Q2 2020 and Q1 2021 when government payments distorted disposable income.
Why we keep an eye on this ratio. In 2007, at the beginning of the Mortgage Crisis, this debt-to-income ratio had gone over 90%! All alarm bells should have sounded long before it got there, and they did but were ignored.
There will always be defaults and foreclosures, triggered by individual events and hardships and miscalculations. The ebbs and flow of economic conditions, such as unemployment, have a broader impact on defaults and foreclosures, but don’t trigger an economy-wide crisis unless leverage is too high.
The widespread mortgage crisis was a result of people being overleveraged in real estate when home prices began to tank.
The 90-plus day delinquency rate edged up for mortgages to 1.13% (red) and dipped for HELOCs to 0.85% (blue).
During the pandemic era’s forbearance programs, delinquency status was removed from delinquent mortgages, which had caused delinquency rates to approach 0%.
In Q3, delinquency rates were about where they’d been in 2018 and 2019 and below where they’d been in 2017 and prior years.
New foreclosures in Q3 rose to 61,900, at the very low end of the three years before the pandemic, far below the number of foreclosures in prior years, and historically low.
During the era of mortgage forbearance and foreclosure bans, foreclosures were essentially impossible.
But now there are some big price declines in some markets, especially with condos, while condo sales have collapsed and supply has spiked.
So I would expect some people, mainly investors who don’t live in their condos, who cannot make the payments and HOA fees, and who cannot sell the condo for enough to pay off the mortgage, to default on the mortgage and end up in foreclosure. But that’s not happening yet in large enough a number to make a visible dent.
Why a housing meltdown won’t topple the banks this time.
About 65% of all mortgages outstanding, including nearly all subprime mortgages, are guaranteed by the US government, via Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Ginnie Mae, FHA (which insures subprime mortgages with low down payments), VA, etc. Getting the government explicitly guaranteeing so many mortgages was one of the most far-reaching changes resulting from the Financial Crisis.
Investors hold about 15% of the mortgages that didn’t qualify for government backing and that were securitized and sold as “private-label” MBS to bond funds and pension funds around the world.
Banks and credit unions hold less than 20% of the total housing debt, and a mortgage meltdown would ruffle some feathers but not threaten to topple them.
And in case you missed it: Household Debts, Debt-to-Income Ratios, Delinquencies, Foreclosures, Collections & Bankruptcies in Q3 2026
Enjoy reading WOLF STREET and want to support it? You can donate. I appreciate it immensely. Click on the mug to find out how:
2012 de ja vu……
2nd homes will be up for grabs again.
I wonder if those stale condo owners might grab a HELOC to the max and bail? Pay off what? Investment debts?
They probably cannot get a HELOC now on an underwater condo. A lender would want to see equity in the condo, so a mortgage balance that is substantially below the current appraised value. Everyone is now aware of the problems with condos.
It baffles me how anyone wasn’t aware of the blindingly obvious problems with condos. Maybe my age is showing but was there a time when condos were priced low enough and inventory high enough to make them appealing to anyone not looking to burn money? Canada excluded of course.
Everytime I’ve looked into condos the sale price is nearly that of a free standing residence of similar size with the added burden of hundreds of dollars a month (or potentially cresting 1k) for dues. Always seemed like a scam to me. Until the pandemic price explosion long term hotels were cheaper monthly with far less headache and included room service.
It depends what you’re getting for it. Pre-COVID, I lived in a condo that was $600/month in fees, but it included Internet, cable, three parking spaces, a nice gym, a heated pool and hot tub, and tennis courts. People like condos, or at least historically did, because you shared those expenses and someone else did all the work for you.
I didn’t have to pay for that stuff separately, so for me it worked. But in a lot of places the fees have gone haywire in the past few years.
Trucker Guy,
Condo HOA fees always include homeowner’s insurance and repairs and maintenance of the property (not inside your walls), in addition to stuff like TSonder305 mentioned. My HOA fee also included hot water, water, garbage, 2 parking spots in the secured garage, a staffed front desk that took deliveries, let visitors in only with your permission, and kept your mail when you went on vacation. And there was a pool on the deck of the parking garage (ca. 8th floor). Well-managed condos are super-convenient no-hassle environments to live in. Condos come in all sizes and price categories. My condo (in Tulsa) had 1,800 sf. Big condos in high-end buildings in expensive cities sell for tens of millions of dollars.
The problem with condos is that many are bought by investors, and there are condo bubbles, driven by investors, that then implode.
wonder how many airbnb properties are bleeding
REIT: Take those underwater Condos and market them in REITs.
These numbers look great. Add in high housing supply and theres room for the market to come down. 2022’s prices are 2030’s prices.
People are incentivized based on recent memory to pay down debt, given the move in rates.
If you owe at 23%/annum on credit cards, getting a HELOC at a FIXED 12%/annum, for example, means if real inflation is 5%, then you are now paying an effective 7%/annum. Higher inflation lowers your effective interest rate!
I will leave whether you can deduct your HELOC interest payments as homework. Hint: for home project? Refinancing works well too.
A slow drag and decay, nothing like the GFC.
(off topic) Weekend memes roundup.
1. Haung Haung bang bang
2. Situation- chip
3. 3 affairs so far. Parallel processing
memory bank – defective
Huang Dang Sweet Poontang
“Why a housing meltdown won’t topple the banks this time.”
As you mentioned, the mortgages are primarily backed by the US Government. So similar individual default levels would do what to the US balance sheet? Wouldn’t that add massive debt on top of that which we’ve accumulated over the past decade(ish)?
I assume the real world result would be far less horrific than the Financial Crisis, but still, added government debt isn’t a walk in the park either.
For us the question of whether to live in a condo – or not – was age related.
When we just graduated from college, were just married, and had little money a condo seemed like a good idea. We took a bath in the results but our parents chipped in.
Then, when we were at the age to want children, we bought our “Forever Home” and lived there for 4 decades. After we paid off the mortgage we got a HELOC … “just in case”.
When my knees gave out, we downsized and went back to living in a Can-Do-Minimum.
Money wise these probably weren’t the best decisions. But I have never considered my shelter to be “an investment”. I’ve always considered it to be “an expense”.
Obviously, others feel differently. Which is OK. Whatever your temperament may be is right for YOU!
Any US guaranteed mortgage problem will get the Lincoln cent solution = Disallowed as a problem. Adding defaulted mortgage balances to the two hundred-something trillion dollar total US debt obligations is just like adding another scoop of sand to Daytona Beach. Officially clipping coinage via the discontinuation of the cent coin is the USA crossing the financial Rubicon, to mix imperial metaphors. Given that unpayable debts have led to hyperinflation, I expect digital payments, as now required at the USPS customers’ counters, to be the fiat dollar’s last chapter.
Right now they’re foreclosing on properties whose mortgages are in default and cannot be cured. There were about 60,000 new foreclosures in Q3, see bottom chart.
Yes, no problem for the banks. But, government guarantees will be paid and that will add to our debt. How much? We’ll find out.
“ About 65% of all mortgages outstanding, including nearly all subprime mortgages, are guaranteed by the US government…”
Is this a legitimate role of government?
I see a fair bit of chatter online about disparities in our economy; recently heard a young fella use a term “Late-Stage Capitalism”, perhaps implying a similarity with late-stage cancer. I tend to differ from this line of thinking. I’m more inclined to view capitalism and the free market as manifestations of natural law.
Yet… there seems to be merit in taking off some of the rough edges of the free market, moderating the extremes.
But dangit, 65% mortgages guaranteed by the US government; that seems like we’re monkeying a bit much with the free market.
There’ll be hell to pay?
During the Financial Crisis, the government ended up bailing out the banks, and the Fed ended up printing a few trillions to bail out the banks. Now the government and the Fed don’t need to bail out anyone, and the Fed doesn’t have to print, because the taxpayer guarantees the mortgages. Properties with defaulted mortgages are being foreclosed on and the losses are taken by the government, so by the taxpayer, but the taxpayer doesn’t care. Bond buyers care, and so they might be demanding higher yields.
Is there a way to segment Mortgage/HELOC to Disposable income by mortgage-holder vs non-mortgage-holder?
It seems unlikely that the BEA income data can be split this way. Which is a shame because the growing share of non-mortgage-holders pulls down the ratio.
Doesn’t make one iota of difference except to social justice warriors. We’re looking here at the overall economy, and if there can be a housing crisis in the overcall economy. There were 60,000 foreclosures in Q3, so they’re happening, but no problem because the number is minuscule. If will likely come up when more condos get foreclosed on, as I pointed out in the article.
Wolf, how is it the case that home sales and condo sales are in the tank, but mortgage balances continue to rise? Surely at the current abysmal rate of transactions, people are paying off their mortgages faster than they are minting new ones. Please help me understand the discrepancy.
1. new homes are being sold and financed with mortgages. About 20% of all home sales are now new home sales. No mortgage gets paid off when a new home is sold, and the entire mortgage is added to the mortgage balance.
2. Basic math: you own a home for 10 years with a $400,000 mortgage and make 10 years of payments. So that mortgage is paid down to some amount, such as to $300,000, and then you sell the home for $600,000 and pay off your $300,000 mortgage (mortgage balance drops by $300,000), while the buyer takes out a $550,000 mortgage to buy your home (mortgage balance rises by $550,000). So that transaction added $250,000 to the overall US mortgage balance.