XユーザーのSoumaya Keynesさん: 「A newly published paper by @zoebcullen is called "Is pay transparency good?"
Note: 10/10, five stars for the clear paper title.
OTHER ECONOMISTS PLEASE TAKE NOTE.
https://t.co/wqafvXGfMt」
A newly published paper by @zoebcullen is called "Is pay transparency good?"
Note: 10/10, five stars for the clear paper title.
OTHER ECONOMISTS PLEASE TAKE NOTE.
How would you feel about everyone knowing your salary? How comfortable would your *boss* feel? Pay transparency measures are increasingly popular. But there are unintended consequences.
My latest for the @FinancialTimes... 🧵
(1st 300 clicks free)
on.ft.com/3wqGohi
A newly published paper by @zoebcullen is called "Is pay transparency good?"
Note: 10/10, five stars for the clear paper title.
OTHER ECONOMISTS PLEASE TAKE NOTE.
It sets out three categories of pay transparency:
(i) VERTICAL: finding out what your boss makes ☝️
(ii) CROSS-FIRM: finding out what you could earn somewhere else (on job ads) 👉
(iii) HORIZONTAL: finding out what your peers make 🖕
☝️ People tend to underestimate what their bosses earn. (They probably haven't replaced their scruffy shoes because they're busy working all the time, not because they're broke.) Enlightening the rank and file can be motivating as they learn the real rewards of promotion.
The EU has a new directive that will force companies to tell employers "objective" criteria for pay and progression. It's not quite telling them why they should want to be the boss, but it could help them get there.
Felix Mitchell of Instant Impact explained to me some companies want to get a sense of the whole market. But failing to share salary bands can waste everyone's time. And it risks setting expectationss according to candidates who may be way out of recruiters' price range.
There has been some noise about companies flouting new requirements to include salaries in job ads, either not doing it at all or else posting wide ranges. This by Simon Quach, David Arnold and @@Bledi_Taska finds that about 2/3rds post salary info darnold199.github.io/pay_transparen…
There is evidence that this kind of cross-firm pay transparency increases overall pay. Perhaps it makes companies fight harder to keep their employees, who now have better info about outside options. Some will like that future employers anchor pay discussions, not past ones.
Side note: The EU is going to bars employers from asking about pay history.
One quant reached out to tell me that he thought employers had dinged him for revealing his low salary during interviews. In theory, such bans can prevent past inequities from becoming entrenched.
🖕 finding out what your peers earn is the most controversial. I heard from folks who learned of other teams being paid more who said they would have rather not known. They said it was grating being asked for help by those they knew were being paid a LOT more than them.
The evidence suggests that measures like gender pay gap reporting do tend to squash gender pay gaps. But they do it by squashing pay growth among men, not lifting it for women. Which is... not ideal.
The EU is ploughing ahead with reforms that will bring in these horizontal pay transparency measures anyway. They are a BIG DEAL.
consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/pa…
Employers are already preparing, especially as rumours are swirling that some governments (the French) might move earlier than the official deadline of 2026. Realistically, the new requirements are probably going to mean more formalised, rigid pay formulae. Which some won't like.
The point is to remove arbitrary judgment from pay and progression decisions. But the risk is that in doing so, managers lose the discretion to reward good performance.
Doing it well can be HARD. Buffer CEO @joelgascoigne recently described how his (uber-transparent) company’s growth warranted a switch from a “salary formula” to a “salary system” with not one but three spreadsheets detailing various inputs